Showing posts with label Mathematical Association of America. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Mathematical Association of America. Show all posts

Friday, June 1, 2012

Response to PCAST

MAA has just made public its official response to the report to President Obama from the President’s Council of Advisors on Science and Technology (PCAST), Report to the President, Engage to Excel: producing one million additional college graduates with degrees in Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics. This response to John Holdren and Eric Lander, the co-chairs of PCAST, is on MAA’s Science Policy page and can be downloaded here. One aspect of the response that I particularly like is the appendix, which lists many MAA activities that align with the PCAST report’s recommendations. Specifically, my synthesis of these recommendations is
1.   To draw on the available research and empirical evidence to improve undergraduate education in mathematics, science, and engineering;
2.   To improve attraction and retention of students by engaging them in activities where they get to discover the science or mathematics; and
3.   To encourage greater collaboration between mathematics and the science and engineering programs.
For this column, I will focus on the subheading to the title of the PCAST report: producing one million additional STEM graduates. As I explained in my March column, On Engaging to Excel, this impressive number is taken over a decade and includes associate’s degrees. Nevertheless, it translates into the still impressive-sounding goal of an additional 75­ to 80,000 bachelor’s degrees in STEM fields each year. How ambitious is that goal?

Graph 1 shows the number of full-time freshmen arriving each fall with the intention of majoring in engineering, as well as the number who graduated with a bachelor’s degree in engineering the previous spring. The most recent number of intended majors is for fall 2011. For actual bachelor’s degrees awarded, the most recent number is for spring 2010.


The most striking feature of this graph is the remarkable consistency in the number of intended Engineering majors from 1980 through 2007 and the dramatic increase since then, from 102,000 in fall 2007 to 184,000 in fall 2011. There are our extra 80,000 STEM majors, if we can keep them. [3]

It is too soon to be able to tell how well we are doing at retention. The first big increase, with the incoming class of fall 2008, has only just seen the graduation of those who completed their degrees in four years. It will be two more years before the US Department of Education releases the spring 2012 graduation numbers. But the situation in the physical and biological sciences can shed some light on what we might expect.


In both cases, the number of intended majors took off following the year 2000, more than doubling over the following decade. In the biological sciences, the annualized rate of growth in the number of bachelor’s degrees from 2005 to 2010 has almost exactly matched the rate of growth in the number of incoming students five years earlier, at about 6% per year. In the physical sciences, the percentage rate of growth in the number of degrees from 2005 to 2010, at 4% per year, is half of the 8% per year growth rate in the number of incoming physical science students five years earlier. It is reasonable to assume that engineering may be more similar to the physical sciences than the biological sciences.

In short, the problem is not with attracting students to STEM fields. The issue will be to retain them.


[1] Higher Education Research Institute. The American Freshman. UCLA.

[2] National Center for Education Statistics. Digest of Education Statistics. US Department of Education.

[3] The increased interest in engineering programs is almost certainly a result of the recession that began in 2008 and the high unemployment rate since then. I discussed this connection in an earlier column, A Benefit of High Unemployment, November 2010. Note that while enrollments in the biological and physical sciences began to increase following the class of 2000, the rates of increase accelerated after 2007.







Tuesday, May 1, 2012

Are Textbooks Better Online?

The March 30 issue of Science included a letter from psychologists David Daniel and Daniel Willingham [1] that provides an excellent overview of what is known about how students use online textbooks, including an account of what we know about the strengths and the weaknesses of switching from print to electronic delivery. I find that what they have to say is in line with my own experiences. For the past year, I have taught our Single Variable Calculus class using MAA’s online textbook Calculus: Modeling and Application, 2nd edition, by David Smith and Lang Moore. This is a direct descendant of their Project CALC materials that I have used and loved. The current edition is only available as an online textbook.

The overwhelming advantage of online publishing is the cost savings. The cost to my students is $25 apiece. This is charged as a lab fee. In exchange, my students get to download the entire textbook onto their own computers, a benefit that is relatively uncommon among online mathematics texts but which my students appreciate because they are not restricted to using their textbook only when they have internet access.

Smith and Moore’s book is written in html, using MathML for the mathematics (which effectively restricts the web browser in which it is read to FireFox). The authors have done a thoughtful job of separating the chapters into sections that each fit fairly comfortably on a single web page. Several of my students have commented on how much that helps with the readability of the text. But my students have found that reading an online textbook does require a period of adjustment.

I have yet to encounter a student who prefers reading web pages instead of printed pages. Daniel and Willingham cite three different studies that confirm that most students prefer traditional print books. Intriguingly, online texts work very well for young readers. In fact, those learning how to read often do better with online books. The difficulties seem to arise when students need to study and learn from the text, a characteristic that is especially true of mathematics books. For reasons that we do not fully understand but which are well documented, careful reading of an electronic text takes longer and is more fatiguing than trying to learn the same material from a printed text. The research also has found that this effect of greater difficulty with electronic texts is independent of the level of familiarity and experience with e-books.

One of the greatest benefits of online textbooks is the ability to embed links to definitions, animations, and software programs. Smith and Moore’s textbook is liberally sprinkled with links to explorations that are available in Maple, Mathcad, and Mathematica. There also are links to WeBWorK, where a library of problems linked to the sections of their book is available.

My own experience is that students frequently ignore the links to explorations unless I specifically assign them. This is in line with the findings reported by Daniel and Willingham: Students often find such ancillary material distracting at best, confusing at worst. Following these links often leads to loosing the thread of the conceptual development in the text. Another characteristic of e-textbooks that can cut both ways is the ability to link to networking sites where they can exchange thoughts about the mathematics and insights into each other’s difficulties. While that can be very beneficial, there is also the danger that these students will be tempted by the distraction of social media that is equally close at hand.

As Daniel and Willingham point out, online textbooks are easily corrected and updated. For the authors of such a text, that means that the job of working on the book is an ongoing task that is never completed, working against the ability to keep the cost down.

The bottom line is that we do not yet know how best to take advantage of online textbooks. Doing it right is clearly not as simple as putting the text on line and inserting links.




[1] David B. Daniel and Daniel T. Willingham. 2012. Electronic Textbooks: Why the Rush? Science. 335. 30 March, 2012. 1570–71.
http://www.sciencemag.org/content/335/6076/1569.full?sid=ba9ce743-5704-4c50-aaef-3f933a3b26ba

Monday, April 2, 2012

MAA/NCTM Joint Position on Calculus

I am very pleased to report that MAA and NCTM (National Council of Teachers of Mathematics) have just approved the joint position statement on calculus that comes at the end of this column. It was crafted in response to the recognition of three serious problems:
  1. The first problem is the general perception among high school students and their parents that preparation for college should, if at all possible, include studying calculus in high school. The result is that too many students short-change their preparation in algebra, geometry, trigonometry, and other mathematical topics in order to stay on a fast track to calculus. Too many otherwise talented students arrive at university without the mathematical foundation that is needed to succeed in the college-level mathematics required for their intended major.
This problem is documented particularly clearly in two national longitudinal studies conducted by the US Department of Education. From the high school class of 1992, 31% of those who completed a course of calculus in 12th grade or earlier then enrolled in precalculus when they got to college.[1] From the high school class of 2004, 17% (one in six) of those who had completed a calculus course in secondary school reported taking remedial mathematics when they got to college.[2]
The solution is to insist that the first priority should be to establish a solid foundation in mathematics, rather than to get into calculus while still in high school.
  1. The second problem is related to the first. It is that too often the calculus course that is taught in high school is a version that trains students in techniques of differentiation and integration and in procedures for solving certain standard problems without developing their understanding of calculus. While this builds familiarity with the language of calculus, it misrepresents the true nature of college-level mathematics and creates a false sense of confidence. One of the most dramatic findings of the MAA’s national study of Calculus I instruction in college and university is the high confidence level of entering students and how precipitously it drops as a result of encountering the reality of college-level expectations for calculus.[3]
The solution is to insist that when calculus is taught in high school, it is taught as a course whose content really is equivalent to a mainstream college course.
  1. The third problem is an outgrowth of the first two. Today’s reality for most students headed into STEM careers is a double dose of introductory calculus, once on each side of the high school to college divide. At the very least, this wastes student time, especially when the college course is taught as if this material were being experienced for the first time. For those students who, for whatever reason, have had a bad or simply uninspiring experience of calculus in secondary school, the prospect of repeating their experience can dissuade them from continuing their study of mathematics. Even for those who enjoyed their secondary school calculus, repeating this course can lead to boredom and poor study habits, often resulting in poor performance and a move away from mathematics intensive disciplines.
The solution is to insist that college faculty recognize their audience and deal with it, modifying how calculus is taught and offering alternatives to calculus for entering students.
Recommendations that address these problems lie at the heart of this position statement. Most satisfying from my point of view is the recognition that the issue of when and how calculus is taught is important and requires the efforts of both MAA and NCTM.

I want to thank all those who have worked to make this joint position statement possible. First is Mike Shaughnessy, President of NCTM, who agreed to make the adoption of such a statement one of his personal priorities. Next is Gail Burrill, former NCTM President and current Chair of the MAA-NCTM Joint Committee on Mutual Concerns who created the framework in which it was possible to craft this statement and who provided much useful feedback during its creation. And finally I want to thank the three people who worked with me to actually write the statement: Mike Boardman at Pacific University, Tom Kilkelly at Wayzata High School in Minnesota, and Dane Camp at New Trier Township High School in Illinois.
Question: How should secondary schools and colleges envision calculus as the course that sits astride the transition from secondary to postsecondary mathematics for most students heading into mathematically intensive careers?
MAA/NCTM Position Although calculus can play an important role in secondary school, the ultimate goal of the K–12 mathematics curriculum should not be to get students into and through a course in calculus by twelfth grade but to have established the mathematical foundation that will enable students to pursue whatever course of study interests them when they get to college. The college curriculum should offer students an experience that is new and engaging, broadening their understanding of the world of mathematics while strengthening their mastery of tools that they will need if they choose to pursue a mathematically intensive discipline.


In particular, the fact that calculus is a college mathematics course that increasingly is taught in high school requires that—
  1. Students who enroll in a calculus course in secondary school should have demonstrated mastery of algebra, geometry, trigonometry, and coordinate geometry;
  2. The calculus course offered in secondary school should have the substance of a mainstream college-level course;
  3. The college curriculum should acknowledge the ubiquity of calculus in secondary school, shape the college calculus curriculum so that it is appropriate for those who have experienced introductory calculus in high school, and offer alternatives to calculus.
Faculty in our colleges and secondary schools should work together to re-envision the role of calculus in secondary and postsecondary mathematics education.  Faculty on both sides of the transition from secondary to college mathematics should work together to strengthen the mathematics curriculum so that students who intend to pursue a mathematically intensive career can acquire the mathematical knowledge and capabilities needed for such a career. College faculty and secondary teachers should define what it means for a student to be ready for college-level mathematics. After a student has matriculated in college, they should assess the effect of college-level mathematics offered in secondary school.  They also should clarify and broaden what is meant by college-level mathematics for secondary school.  They should also work to achieve a better understanding of the mathematical strengths and weaknesses of matriculating students, assess the effectiveness of placement programs for collegiate mathematics, and clarify and broaden what the first year of college mathematics can and should entail.


MAA and NCTM are committed to taking appropriate action within the structure of their organizations to assist in guiding the implementation of these recommendations.


[1] US Department of Education. 2008. National Education Longitudinal Study of 1988 (NELS:88). nces.ed.gov/surveys/NEL


[2] National Science Board. Science and Engineering Indicators: 2010. National Science Foundation. Arlington, VA. Appendix Table 1-20. www.nsf.gov/statistics/seind10/appendix.htm


[3] The MAA study Characteristics of Successful Programs in College Calculus found that 61% of the students in college Calculus I had studied calculus in high school, and 58% of all the students starting Calculus I expected to earn an A in the course. Confidence was the greatest single casualty of the course, dropping by almost half a standard deviation from the start to the end of the course.